Short-Term or Long-Term Rental: Which Is Right for Your Beit Shemesh Property?

Furnished guest apartment with a comparison of short-term and long-term rental in Beit Shemesh

A twelve-month lease or a calendar full of visiting families? For apartment owners in Ramat Beit Shemesh, it’s one of the first decisions after the keys are handed over. It’s also one of the most important.

Many owners bought in RBS Aleph, Rama Gimmel or Neve Shamir while still living in New Jersey, London or Toronto, with aliyah a few years down the road. In the meantime, the apartment has to earn its keep. Some owners want steady, hands-off income. Others want the freedom to use the home themselves for Pesach or a grandson’s bar mitzvah. Both goals are reasonable. They just lead to very different properties.

What’s the Difference Between Short-Term and Long-Term?

A long-term rental is a standard residential lease, usually for a year or more. One family moves in, and in most leases the tenant pays arnona and utilities directly. Your job is to collect the rent, handle repairs and renew the contract.

A short-term rental, often called a zimmer or holiday apartment, is let by the night or the week, fully furnished. The owner usually covers electricity, water, arnona, internet, cleaning and linen. In essence, a long-term rental is a property investment. A short-term rental is a small hospitality business.

Which Earns More?

Start with the long-term benchmark. According to Ynet, drawing on Central Bureau of Statistics data released in May 2026, the average monthly rent in Israel reached NIS 5,027, up 3.5% year on year. The same report puts the average in Beit Shemesh at NIS 4,782, about $1,655 a month.

Rents are also moving faster for new leases than for existing ones. In April 2026, rents for new tenants rose 5.9% while renewing tenants saw 2.2%, per the same report. Appraiser Shmulik Cohen of S.K. Real Estate Appraisal explained the logic: “When there is a decline in home purchases, demand for rentals rises.”

Short-term income works differently. A busy week over Sukkot can bring in what a long-term lease earns in a month. Then the apartment can sit empty for most of Cheshvan. Consequently, the honest comparison isn’t your best week against a monthly rent. It’s your realistic yearly occupancy, minus cleaning, utilities, furnishing and management, against twelve months of steady rent.

When Is Short-Term Demand Strongest in RBS?

Beit Shemesh isn’t Tel Aviv, and its short-term market doesn’t run on tourists alone. Demand here is driven by family. Grandparents fly in for Pesach and Sukkot. Parents visit children in seminary and yeshiva. Relatives come for weddings, bar mitzvahs and sheva brachos, and need somewhere within walking distance of the shul and the hall.

That makes the calendar a bit like a pressure cooker. The chagim and summer fill up months ahead, simchas create sudden spikes, and the winter weeks are quiet. Add to the mix a wider tourism market that is still rebuilding. According to Tourism Ministry figures reported by JNS, about 1.3 million tourists visited Israel in 2025, with signs of recovery after the October ceasefire.

What does this mean in practice? A well-located short-term apartment near the main shuls of RBS Aleph or Neve Shamir can do well in peak weeks. But you should plan for uneven months, not an even stream.

How Is Rental Income Taxed in Israel?

This is where the two options split sharply. For long-term residential rentals, Israeli individuals can choose between three tracks, as Globes explains:

  • Exemption track. According to Kol Zchut, monthly residential rent up to NIS 5,654 (the figure it gives as of 2026) is tax-free. Above that, a partial exemption shrinks to zero at NIS 11,308. The tenant must use the apartment as a home.
  • 10% track. A flat 10% on gross rent, with no deduction for expenses or depreciation. Kol Zchut notes the tax is paid once a year, by 30 January of the following year.
  • Regular track. Rent taxed at your marginal rate, with expenses, including depreciation, deducted.

With the average Beit Shemesh rent at NIS 4,782, many local long-term leases sit under the exemption ceiling. That’s a significant advantage.

Short-term rentals don’t get it. Globes reported in March 2025 that short-term apartment and room rentals don’t qualify for these tracks. They’re treated as business income, at marginal rates that can reach about 50%. If you live abroad, your home country may tax the same income too. These figures are as reported at the dates shown, and this is not tax advice. Confirm your own position with an Israeli accountant, and a cross-border one if you file overseas.

What About Regulation?

Unfortunately, the rules for short-term rentals are still unsettled. In March 2025, the Knesset Finance Committee dropped a proposal to make platforms such as Airbnb and Booking.com report every booking to the Tax Authority, per the same Globes report. The Finance Minister has said he will keep pushing for a reporting requirement, so owners should assume more transparency is coming, not less.

Municipalities can also act through property tax. Tel Aviv, for example, announced plans back in 2019 to raise taxes on short-term accommodation, reported The Times of Israel. Closer to home, check your building’s house rules and talk to the vaad bayit. Neighbours who share a stairwell will notice a new family arriving every Thursday night.

Who Does the Work, and What Does It Cost the Apartment?

A long-term rental needs attention a few times a year. A handover, a dripping tap, a contract renewal. A short-term rental needs attention every week: guest messages, key handovers, cleaning between bookings, fresh linen, and the air conditioner that fails an hour before Shabbat.

Wear and tear follows the same pattern. More guests mean more scuffed walls, tired mattresses and replaced towels, and furniture that has to look good in every listing photo. Budget for it from day one. From abroad, none of this works without a reliable local team on the ground.

Which Option Fits You?

So how can you decide? Start with what you want from the apartment, then test it against the numbers:

  1. Choose long-term if you want predictable income, minimal involvement and the residential tax tracks. It suits most owners living overseas.
  2. Consider short-term if the apartment is furnished, close to shuls and halls, and you want to use it yourself for chagim or family simchas.
  3. Run a realistic year. Estimate occupancy month by month, including the quiet winter weeks, not just Pesach.
  4. Subtract every cost. Cleaning, linen, utilities, arnona, internet, furnishing, repairs and management.
  5. Compare after tax. A long-term rent under the exemption ceiling may out-earn a busier short-term calendar taxed as business income.
  6. Check the building. Read the house rules and speak to the vaad bayit before you list.
  7. Line up management. Decide who answers the phone, turns the apartment around and handles emergencies.

Some owners do both: a long-term lease for most of the year while they’re abroad, and the apartment kept back for their own family visits once they make aliyah.

Looking Ahead

Rents in Beit Shemesh are still climbing, and family travel to Israel is rebuilding. Either way, a well-run apartment in RBS has real earning power. The key is matching the strategy to your goals, your calendar and your tolerance for hands-on work.

We manage both kinds of rental under one roof. For short-term rentals, call Yosef at 055-337-1969 or list your apartment on Find a Zimmer, our short-term rental site for Beit Shemesh. For long-term rentals, property management or anything else, call Reuven at 052-561-0702 or learn more at reuvenjacob.com.

Sources

Join The Discussion